By John ~ September 29th, 2008.
The full title of this book by Alice Feiring is The Battle for Wine and Love or How I Saved the World from Parkerization. Without the subtitle, I donâ€™t believe this book would have sold 10 copies. Alice hasnâ€™t saved the world from anything. In my opinion, she has a strange palate that seems to mirror her personality and her thoughts on many subjects. In truth I believe she has an inner longing to be as popular as Robert Parker and is jealous of his fame.
She seems to want to move winemaking back to the 60â€™s and 70â€™s when every other bottle was bad, sanitation sucked, and winemaking ethics were a sad joke. I donâ€™t. I started drinking wine when Alice was still in diapers, and I do not long for the â€œgood old daysâ€ in wine any more than in real life. I believe that wine quality across the board is better than it has ever been in my life.
Ms. Feiring really reveals her personal biases, certainly not any great intelligence, when she expounds on Australian Shiraz and the fact that there is only one Shiraz in all of Australia that she actually likes. I wonder how many she has tasted because she admits that she has never visited Australia. And yet in another section in her book, she talks about how important it is to visit the vineyards and get to know the winemakers and what makes them tick before forming an opinion about their wine.
Then she digs an even bigger hole for herself when she asks why anyone would want to go from France to Australia to learn about Syrah when France has over 150 years of Syrah winemaking history from which to draw. Well, I hate to burst Aliceâ€™s bubble, but Australia also has over 150 years of history making Shiraz (Syrah). I know because Iâ€™ve been there and Iâ€™ve tasted hundreds of those old-vine Shiraz.Â Certainly some Shirazes are better than others, and I donâ€™t agree with all of Parkerâ€™s touts on them, but to blast them across the board is ridiculous.
Why doesnâ€™t Alice just say that her palate is different than some of the more famous wine writers today and leave it at that rather than implying that anyone who doesnâ€™t fall in love with her favorite Loire reds (Cabernet Franc) is a nut? I only observed one nut while reading this book and it was the author.
In my opinion, Alice is just trying to sell books and promote Aliceâ€¦and she seems to be doing a good job of both. If you are looking for a good and balanced book on wine or advice on what to drink, I suggest that you look elsewhere.
Have you read The Battle for Wine and Love? If so, what are your thoughts on it?
Filed under: Wine Books